When I received an email from the Office of the Premier of British Columbia on February 10 I was curiously intrigued. How did they get my name and private email and what did they want?
I found that it was an invitation to join a conversation lead by Dr. Robert Daum, the third such dialogue he has conducted.
The discussion convened some of the key government leaders responsible for charting a course for us through the pandemic, and about 40 spiritual, faith and indigenous leaders in the province who are navigating their people through this crisis based on those charts. The meeting would take place February 22.
Their stated objective was to consult us about…
The community impacts of the pandemic, evolving heath orders and related issues. This dialogue will focus on the considerations required to safely ease government restrictions. When it becomes possible to begin to ease public health restrictions, what is important for government to know about your community context? Several provincial government officials will be at this dialogue. As well, there will be an update on the vaccination process.
In that moment I had an idea and created a survey to get the pulse of my peers who were not invited to this meeting – charismatic and evangelical leaders of churches and Christian ministries in British Columbia. In the survey I asked a few simple questions to help me prepare for this meeting (the survey results are below).
Remember, I’m not a pollster so I didn’t have a methodology in mind and I probably could have worded the questions better. But I asked questions that I wanted answers for to help me as I walk with churches and ministries in the province as they navigate this crisis.
I forwarded the link to the survey to many of the the leaders that I know and asked that it be forwarded among a number of leadership groups that I belong to.
I kept it off social media but soon discovered that it had struck a nerve as I began to get replies from all over the province. I was originally only hoping for a few dozen replies but by the time the survey closed on February 21 at 9 PM there were 150 completed surveys and an inbox full of email messages.
Too late for me to adjust the survey questions, the Friday before the meeting I received the link to the meeting along with these questions we would be asked:
“What strategies can you envision to balance the need for public health restrictions and the needs of your community in terms of in-person gathering?”
“What would success look like to you when the Province takes safe, careful steps to ease health restrictions? What concerns should the Province be aware of in this process?”
Faith Leaders Meeting
At the meeting the thoughts expressed in this survey were repeated by those in many of the other faith groups represented. Time and again leaders expressed that they want to be treated by the government with fairness and with a strategy which would allow their buildings to remain open for gatherings as has been the case with restaurants and gyms.
This issue was well expressed recently in Pastor Samuel Chua’s open letter to Dr. Bonnie Henry: https://churchforvancouver.ca/open-letter-from-a-pastor-to-dr-bonnie-henry-and-minister-adrian-dix/
A large part of the meeting was given over to breakout groups that discussed the issues. I represented the Charismatic and Evangelical community and in my group there was a leader from the Catholic, Anglican, Jewish, Muslim, Ismaili, Mormon, and Hindu communities.
I was uncertain how the views represented by my survey would be received by these leaders but as I presented the findings I found that they agreed with them and that it helped them give voice to their own concerns about where we are at now.
I expected broad support for the government among these leaders from other faith groups, but discovered that the general level of favour once enjoyed by Premier John Horgan and Provincial Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry among faith communities has evaporated, leaving behind uneasy compliance and the rumblings of opposition.
One leader in my group was Gordon Oliver of Kelowna, who does public relations for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints in the interior of BC. The leaders in our group gratefully acknowledged that he put into words what we were all thinking and feeling when he said that, “our desire for the safety of the people that attend our services is equal to or greater than that of the government”.
The response generated by that comment was enormous, with most saying that they wanted to be treated with fairness and respect and that the government’s one size fits all approach was wrong headed and unhelpful.
As you look at the survey responses you will notice that while many churches and ministries will continue to follow the health orders and closures there is growing opposition to the government and a willingness among some faith leaders to move into civil disobedience in order to serve their communities.
Two key responses that reveal the loss of government support are that while 64% of these churches and ministries will continue to follow the closure orders only 36% of them support the government’s handling of churches and ministries during this crisis. That is a lot of passive aggressive compliance that could explode into opposition.
Leaders in this meeting continued to express their desire for the government to recognize faith communities as essential services.
Those familiar with the Halo Project (https://www.haloproject.ca/) will know that shutting down the operation of faith communities has a significant impact on the surrounding community since “every dollar a congregation spends could create $4.77 worth of service a city does not have to provide.”
There were two government presentations during the meeting, one from Minister of Health Adrian Dix, on the court case and one from Dr. Penny Ballem, on the provincial immunization rollout. Summaries of their presentations follow. You can skip these and scroll down to review the survey results below.
Rev. Shannon Stange
Statement from the BC Government on the court case initiated by some churches against the province
Minister Dix reported on the success of the vaccinations program in long term care facilities.
However, he stated that given the lack of vaccines, “Provincial health orders and our efforts for social distancing will need to be maintained to some degree well into the future. While vaccines are an answer and they may be an answer by September, they are not an answer for March for lifting health orders.”
Turning his attention to the court case that was brought against the province by a number of churches he said:
“Our view is that people have the absolute right to go to court and that we are going to argue these issues in the court…. It’s critically important that provincial health orders be followed…. For those judgements, we understand that there are consequences to public health orders.”
For those judgements, we understand that there are consequences to public health orders.
– Minister of Health, Adrian Dix
He seems to be saying that the government will continue it’s adversarial stance with communities of faith. He was not willing to acknowledge that these communities are pushing back because of the inequity of the BC government shutting down faith gatherings when they could easily allow those gatherings with reasonable safety protocols as they do for businesses.
Immunization Rollout Briefing
The dialogue session ended with a very helpful presentation by Dr. Penny Ballem, who explained that she has no say in policy as her role is a strictly technical one with the responsibility for the immunization rollout in BC. She gave permission to share her slides which are below or can be downloaded here as a PDF.
After her presentation she fielded questions from the leaders. Here is a short summary of the questions about the vaccines with her answers:
Q. Are we able to offer our churches as vaccination centres?
A. We are only looking for larger buildings which can house clinics. These are being organized right now. That list will be publicly available soon.
Q. Are there allergic reactions to the vaccines?
A. There are very few reactions but it has not been tested in young people so all our data is from those 18 years and older. The only significant reaction is to PEG (Polyethylene glycol) which is the storage solution used in the vaccine.
Q. How will the government help those get vaccinated, who lack access in remote locations both physically and technologically?
A. We will have a provincial call centre so all that people will need is a phone. We encourage you to help those who are elderly or isolated.
Q. Is there a risk for women who are pregnant or struggling with fertility?
A. There is no indication that there is any risk to fertility. If you are pregnant it is important to discuss this with your doctor before receiving the vaccine.
Q. How soon after receiving a vaccination can one go back to normal routines and stop following health guidelines such as wearing a mask?
A. That is a question that only Dr. Bonnie Henry can answer.
Q. Is it compulsory for every citizen to receive the vaccine?
A. There is no requirement for people to be vaccinated but we encourage it.
Official Government Sites
The latest province wide restrictions for all sectors.
Look on that page for the information on:
• Funerals, weddings, and baptisms, and
• Religious gatherings and worship services.
Additionally, here are the latest recommendations from the BC Centre for Disease Control
Responses Submitted in the Survey
The following are the unedited written responses from the submitted surveys. You can read all the responses to the questions asked and see how they relate to the leaders views regarding their support for the government and their views about how they will respond to continued closure orders. Use the Focus Mode at the top right of each question to open all the responses to that question.